Bad Santa
written by John Requa and Glenn Ficarra
directed by Terry Zwigoff
*** (out of ****)
I feel lucky. I happen to like Terry Zwigoff's movies almost as much as I like the "idea" of Terry Zwigoff. On the basis of only two films, this middle-aged slub is my favourite director working in Hollywood, and this third does nothing to diminish my esteem of him. Sure, it doesn't reach the heights of Ghost World or Crumb, but it's better than it has any right in being. Just try describing the premise of the movie to someone in a way that makes it sound at all appealing. Bet you can't do it.
When I heard that Zwigoff had initially wanted Bill Murray to play the lead as the surly, alcoholic safe cracker (and part-time shopping mall Santa Claus), I cursed Sophia Coppola. I cursed her to hell. (Needless to say, I was underwhelmed by critical fave Lost in Translation.)
But after having seen the movie, I can't imagine Murray in the role anymore, and for one simple reason: I can't imagine Murray obsessing over Lauren Graham's ass. Or anyone's ass. Coppola might have opened her film with a shot of Scarlett Johansson's backside, but its artful, tasteful framing is more in keeping with Murray's chasteness. (Only Johansson's gaze during a karaoke serenade approaches anything like lust.) In Lost in Translation, like in Wes Anderson's Rushmore, Murray is sexless. I think that's what audiences are responding to, especially the brief encounter in Translation. (Certainly it says something about our culture where the lack of a character's sexuality is proof of his romanticism.)
There's nothing "tasteful" about Billy Bob Thorton. There are no illusions. Billy Bob wants to fuck.
Thorton may be the best actor you've never thought of. He's such a great talent, but he's so bereft of the kind of nods or flourishes that others often use to key you into his "performance". Other than Will Ferrell's similarly unmannered (albeit more extreme) work this year as the Elf, it's the best comedic performance I've seen since Gene Hackman in Anderson's otherwise too precious Royal Tannenbaums What makes Thorton so good? A total yet controlled immersion into the character.
Zwigoff and Thorton aren't miracle workers. They can't overcome a script whose various plots threads never really coalesce. (It feels like you're watching three different, shorter movies... fortunately, all those movies star Thorton and are directed by Zwigoff.) Unfortunately, the main narrative is far and away the weakest strand, playing out the one-joke premise of the title with little development. It's a funny joke--don't get me wrong--and Bernie Mac and John Ritter also do good work in the process. (Zwigoff and editor Robert Hoffman give their exchanges such a musical rhythm, and throughout the film they use the often staid shot/reverse-shot convention to great comedic effect.)
But it's Thorton's relationships with a randy, Santa-obsessed barmaid (Graham) and especially an unflappable little boy (a wonderfully peculiar Brett Kelly) showcase the film's latent greatness. I wish there was more for Graham to do in her first major post-Gilmore role, but she's relaxed and soulful in a way that the token love interest never usually is. Fortunately, Kelly's robotic holiday cheer proves a hilarious counter to Thorton's cynicism, and their relationship deepens in a way that most Christmas films usually botch. (Even the Elf, for all its wonderfulness, falters when it comes to the "sappy" parts.) There's nothing "sappy" about Bad Santa, even at its most heartfelt. Zwigoff's not a hipster. He's an outsider. The difference is crucial. No matter how pointed the humour becomes, he's no ironist, and instead keeps the emotions real. Zwigoff is never aloof. More than anything else, it's that difference in attitude that seperates Zwigoff, grizzled by life not from a career in the "industry", from his younger contemporaries.
And yes, that's the same theme from Kubrick's Eyes Wide Shut--Shostakovich's Jazz Waltz #2--in the background. Thora Birch, Lauren Graham, Stanley Kubrick, and Shostakovich--the man's got great taste in women, movies, and music.